Field sobriety tests
Field sobriety test medical conditions are not a defense lawyer’s invention. The federal manual officers train from says people over 65, people with back, leg or inner-ear problems, and people who are significantly overweight may have difficulty with the walk-and-turn and one-leg-stand, and that heels over two inches should come off. When a sober person’s body, shoes or surroundings explain the “clues,” the test stops measuring impairment.
Key takeaways
- NHTSA’s 2023 SFST manual itself lists age, back, leg and inner-ear problems, weight and high heels as limitations.
- The original research behind the tests included very few older adults (under 1.5% were over 65) and reported no weight data.
- Officers are trained to ask about illness, injury, diabetes, epilepsy and medications before testing; the answers belong in the report.
- North Carolina courts treat HGN as scientific evidence and weigh every SFST clue in the totality of the circumstances, so medical explanations can change probable-cause and trial outcomes.
Can medical conditions affect field sobriety tests?
Yes. The walk-and-turn and one-leg-stand are balance and coordination tasks, and anything that affects balance or coordination in a sober person, from an old knee injury to an inner-ear disorder, can produce the same “clues” officers are trained to read as alcohol impairment. Horizontal gaze nystagmus (HGN) can also be affected by certain eye and neurological conditions.
That is why the standardized tests come with standardized limitations. The three-test battery was validated under specific conditions, on specific people, with specific instructions. When the person or the setting falls outside those conditions, the test’s accuracy figures no longer describe what happened at the roadside. Our complete guide to the SFST battery in North Carolina explains how each test is supposed to work; this article focuses on what can skew them.
What NHTSA’s own manual says about limitations
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s DWI Detection and Standardized Field Sobriety Testing participant manual (revised February 2023) is the curriculum North Carolina officers are trained on. It contains its own warnings about who may struggle with the divided-attention tests.
The manual also tells officers, before deciding to have a driver step out, to be alert for medical conditions that mimic impairment and to ask questions such as: Do you have any physical disabilities? Are you sick or injured? Are you under the care of a doctor or dentist? Are you diabetic or epileptic (and, if diabetic, do you take insulin)? Are you on any medications? Those questions exist because the people who wrote the curriculum knew medical conditions can look like intoxication.

Age: balance declines whether you have been drinking or not
Balance on one leg declines steadily with age in completely sober people, which makes the one-leg-stand’s 30-second count a very different task at 70 than at 25. NHTSA’s own manual acknowledges that fewer than 1.5% of the original test subjects were over 65.
Clinical research on healthy adults shows how steep the decline is. In a study of 549 healthy, sober adults published in the Journal of Geriatric Physical Therapy (Springer et al., 2007), participants stood barefoot on one leg with eyes open for up to 45 seconds. Average times fell from about 43 seconds in the 18–39 group to 27 seconds in people in their 60s and 15 seconds in their 70s. The study used a clinical protocol, not the roadside test, but the trend is the point: a sober 70-year-old may not be able to hold one leg up for 30 seconds on a level floor, let alone a sloped shoulder at night.
For an older driver, the questions to ask are whether the officer asked about age-related conditions, whether the report notes the person’s age at all, and whether the officer relied on balance tests the manual itself says older adults may have trouble with. Our one-leg-stand guide explains the four clues and how they are scored.
Weight and body type
NHTSA’s manual says people overweight by 50 or more pounds may have difficulty with the one-leg-stand, yet it also concedes that the final research report contained no data on test subjects’ weight. That means the tests were never validated on heavier drivers in any documented way.
Body size affects the walk-and-turn too: heel-to-toe walking on a narrow line, keeping the arms at the sides, and pivoting with small steps are harder for people with large frames, wide stances, knee or hip strain, or limited ankle flexibility. A swaying or arms-out clue in a heavy, sober person may be biomechanics, not alcohol. See our walk-and-turn guide for the eight clues.
Inner ear, neurological and eye conditions
The vestibular system in the inner ear controls balance and eye stability, so inner-ear disorders can affect both the balance tests and the eye tests. NHTSA’s manual acknowledges that nystagmus can be caused by brain damage, some inner-ear diseases and other pathological disorders, and that some people have natural, long-standing nystagmus.
- Vestibular disorders such as vertigo, Ménière’s disease or labyrinthitis can cause unsteadiness and dizziness on turns and one-leg balance.
- Head injuries and concussions, including from a crash moments earlier, can slow speech, impair balance and affect eye movement.
- Neurological conditions like multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, neuropathy or a prior stroke can affect gait, balance and coordination.
- Eye conditions, including congenital nystagmus, unequal pupils, a prosthetic eye or strabismus, can interfere with HGN. The manual requires officers to check for equal pupil size, resting nystagmus and equal tracking before scoring HGN, precisely to screen these out.
Our deep dives on the HGN test, vertical gaze nystagmus and lack of convergence explain the eye science in detail.
Diabetes, low blood sugar, fatigue and illness
Low blood sugar (hypoglycemia) can cause confusion, sweating, shakiness, slurred speech and poor coordination, a cluster that can look a lot like intoxication. That is why NHTSA’s pre-exit questions specifically ask about diabetes and insulin.

Other ordinary conditions matter too. Extreme fatigue after a double shift, a migraine, a fever, dehydration after a long day on the water, anxiety, and some prescription medications all affect balance and attention. Lawful medication can still support a DWI charge if it impairs you (see prescription drug DWI in NC), but a medical explanation for specific clues is still relevant evidence. If an officer suspects drugs rather than alcohol, a Drug Recognition Expert evaluation may follow, and DREs are trained to rule out medical causes.
Injuries, arthritis, and back and leg problems
Any injury below the waist, and many above it, changes how a person walks, turns and balances. Back, leg and inner-ear problems are the specific limitations NHTSA names for both balance tests.
Common examples include knee or hip replacements, arthritis, plantar fasciitis, a recently sprained ankle, sciatica, prior back surgery, foot neuropathy and pregnancy. Some leave visible evidence (a brace, a limp, a surgical scar), but many do not. The officer’s notes should reflect whether the question was asked and what the driver said. Our hypothetical case study on field sobriety tests and an ankle injury shows how this plays out, and our article on the Modified Romberg and other non-standardized tests covers tests that were never validated at all.
Footwear, surface, lighting and weather
The original research recommended a dry, hard, level, non-slippery surface and relatively safe conditions, with room for nine heel-to-toe steps. Heels over two inches should be removed. Real roadsides often fall short.


- Footwear. High heels, platform shoes, flip-flops, slides, cowboy boots and work boots all change balance. Removing shoes helps with heels but creates its own problems on gravel, hot pavement or cold asphalt.
- Surface. Road crown, sloped shoulders, gravel, grass, wet pavement and painted lines with raised reflectors all make a straight line harder to follow.
- Lighting. Flashing emergency lights and headlights can distract and affect balance, and they can make HGN harder to administer properly.
- Weather and traffic. Wind, rain and cold, and trucks passing a few feet away, compete for the driver’s attention in tests that are designed to divide attention.
Body-camera and dash-camera video is often the best evidence of these conditions; see how to get dashcam and bodycam footage in a NC DWI. And remember that the tests are voluntary in North Carolina; our article on refusing field sobriety tests explains what declining really means.

How North Carolina courts treat field sobriety evidence
North Carolina courts let officers describe what they saw on the balance tests as lay observations, treat HGN as scientific evidence that needs a proper foundation, and weigh every clue in the totality of the circumstances. Medical explanations therefore matter at two stages: the probable-cause hearing and trial.
A witness may give expert testimony solely on the issue of impairment, and not on a specific alcohol concentration, about the results of an HGN test administered in accordance with the person’s training by someone who has successfully completed HGN training, and, if the witness holds a current Drug Recognition Expert certification, about whether a person was under the influence of an impairing substance and its category.
Read the rule on ncleg.gov ↗Notice the phrase “in accordance with the person’s training.” If the officer skipped the equal-pupil, resting-nystagmus and equal-tracking checks, or tested someone whose eye condition the training says to screen out, that is a foundation issue. The cases below show how courts approach SFST evidence.
HGN is a scientific test; an officer’s 40-hour training alone was not a sufficient foundation for testimony about what HGN results mean, and admitting it without proof of reliability required a new trial.
Read the opinion ↗A trial court need not use magic words to qualify an officer as an HGN expert under Rule 702; the record showed the judge implicitly recognized the officer’s expertise. Qualification and scope still matter.
Read the opinion ↗An admission to drinking, red glassy eyes, a moderate odor, six HGN clues, missed steps on the walk-and-turn and swaying on the one-leg-stand supported probable cause even without bad driving or slurred speech. SFST clues carry real weight, which is why medical explanations for them matter.
Read the opinion ↗Where the driver completed the roadside tests acceptably, had only a light odor and showed no slurred speech or stumbling, the trial court properly found no probable cause; performance on the tests is weighed with everything else.
Read the opinion ↗Slurred speech and lack of muscular coordination observed during sobriety testing are nontestimonial physical evidence, so Miranda does not bar them. Because the State can use your body’s performance as evidence, the medical reasons behind that performance matter.
Read the opinion ↗For the probable-cause framework, see our breakdowns of State v. Parisi and State v. Godwin, or browse the full NC DWI case-law library.
A clue is only a clue if a sober version of the same person, in the same shoes, on the same shoulder, would have passed.Adkins & Purkey
How to document a medical condition after a DWI arrest
A medical explanation is only as strong as its proof. Records created before the arrest are usually the most persuasive because no one can say they were made for the case.
- Write down what you told the officer
Did the officer ask about injuries, illness, diabetes or medications? What did you say? Note your shoes, the surface, the lighting and the weather.
- Gather prior medical records
Diagnoses, imaging, surgery reports, physical therapy notes and prescriptions that pre-date the stop.
- Get a treating provider’s letter
A short letter from your doctor describing the condition and how it affects balance, gait or eye movement can help, especially for HGN-related conditions.
- Preserve the video
Body-camera and in-car video shows the surface, footwear and your actual performance better than any notes.
- Photograph your shoes and any brace or device
Keep the actual shoes you wore if footwear is an issue.
Use this checklist to track what you have collected. It saves on your device only.
- List of diagnoses that affect balance, gait, vision or speech
- Medical records dated before the arrest
- Current medication list with doses and times taken
- Glucose readings or diabetes logs for that day, if diabetic
- Photos of the shoes worn and any brace, cane or orthotic
- Notes on the surface, slope, lighting, weather and traffic
- Body-camera and dash-camera video request
- Officer’s SFST scoring notes and narrative from discovery
According to NHTSA’s manual, what share of the original walk-and-turn test subjects were over 65?
- About 25%
- Less than 1.5%
- About 10%
The 2023 manual states that less than 1.5% of the original test subjects were over 65.
What does the manual say about heels?
- Nothing
- Heels must always stay on
- People in heels over 2 inches should be given the opportunity to remove them
The manual says individuals wearing heels more than 2 inches high should be given the chance to remove their shoes.
Which question is on NHTSA’s list of medical questions?
- “Are you diabetic or epileptic?”
- “What is your blood type?”
- “When did you last see an eye doctor?”
The manual lists questions about disabilities, illness or injury, a doctor’s care, diabetes or epilepsy, insulin and medications.
In North Carolina, HGN results are treated as:
- Lay opinion any witness can give
- Scientific evidence requiring a proper foundation
- Inadmissible in all cases
State v. Helms (1998) held HGN is a scientific test; Rule 702(a1) now governs expert HGN testimony on impairment.

From our book
Charged with DWI in North Carolina?
Our book walks through each field sobriety test the way officers are trained to give it, and the medical and environmental factors that can make a sober person look impaired.
Get the ebook at Barnes & Noble ↗ Amazon Kindle ↗ Amazon paperback (print) ↗
Field sobriety tests and medical conditions: FAQ
Can a medical condition make me fail a field sobriety test?
Yes. NHTSA’s own manual says people over 65, people with back, leg or inner-ear problems and people overweight by 50 or more pounds may have difficulty with the balance tests, and some eye and neurological conditions can affect HGN.
Should I tell the officer about my medical condition?
Officers are trained to ask about injuries, illness, diabetes, epilepsy and medications. Briefly and accurately mentioning a real condition that affects balance or vision can be documented in the report. You are not required to perform field sobriety tests in North Carolina.
Do high heels or flip-flops affect the walk-and-turn?
They can. The manual says people in heels over 2 inches should be offered the chance to remove them, and loose footwear like flip-flops gives little support for heel-to-toe walking and pivoting.
Does being overweight affect field sobriety tests?
NHTSA’s manual says people overweight by 50 or more pounds may have difficulty with the one-leg-stand, while admitting the original final report had no data on subjects’ weight.
Can diabetes look like being drunk?
Low blood sugar can cause confusion, sweating, shakiness, slurred speech and poor coordination. That is why NHTSA trains officers to ask whether a driver is diabetic and takes insulin.
How do I prove a medical condition affected my tests?
Pre-arrest medical records, a treating provider’s letter, your medication list and the body-camera video are usually the strongest proof.
Adkins & Purkey, PLLC
Talk to a North Carolina DWI lawyer
If an injury, medical condition, age or the roadside conditions affected your field sobriety tests, the records and video should be gathered early. Offices in Huntersville (Lake Norman) and Locust (Stanly County), serving Charlotte, Mecklenburg, Iredell, Cabarrus, Stanly and courts across North Carolina.
General North Carolina legal information as of November 2026, not legal advice for any specific case. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.



