Traffic stops & investigation

Weaving inside your own lane is not a traffic violation in North Carolina, and by itself it usually does not justify a DWI stop. But a weaving DWI stop in North Carolina can be lawful when the weaving is “constant and continual,” erratic and dangerous, or paired with “plus” factors like a late hour or nearby bars. Where your case falls on that line can decide whether the evidence is ever heard.

Key takeaways

  • State v. Fields (2009): three drifts to the line over 1.5 miles at 4 p.m. was not enough.
  • State v. Otto (2012): constant weaving for three-quarters of a mile at 11 p.m. on a Friday was enough.
  • State v. Kochuk (2013): weaving plus touching lane lines at 1:10 a.m. was enough.
  • State v. Derbyshire (2013): one weave at 10:05 p.m. on a Wednesday was not enough.
  • Video, distance, time and road design usually decide these motions.

Is weaving within your lane illegal in North Carolina?

No. Weaving that stays inside your lane does not appear to violate any North Carolina traffic law. The lane statute, G.S. 20-146(d)(1), requires a vehicle to be driven “as nearly as practicable entirely within a single lane” and not moved out of it until the driver has made sure the move is safe. A car that drifts from the center line to the fog line without crossing either is, by definition, still in its lane.

G.S. 20-146(d)(1)Driving within a single lane

On roads divided into two or more clearly marked lanes, a vehicle must be driven as nearly as practicable entirely within a single lane and must not be moved from that lane until the driver has first made sure the movement can be made with safety.

Read the statute on ncleg.gov ↗

That matters because a traffic stop needs a legal justification. If the officer saw a violation — speeding, a lane violation, a dead tag — the stop is usually valid on that basis alone. When the only thing the officer saw was in-lane weaving, the stop has to rest instead on reasonable suspicion that the driver was impaired. That is where the North Carolina weaving cases come in.

Lane markings and traffic on Interstate 77 in Charlotte, North Carolina
Lane lines define the legal question: did the car leave its lane, or only move within it? Interstate 77, Charlotte. Photo: Adam Moss, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

The legal test: reasonable suspicion and the “totality”

An officer may stop a car to investigate DWI only with reasonable, articulable suspicion based on specific facts, judged by the totality of the circumstances. It is a lower bar than probable cause, but it is not a hunch. Both the Fourth Amendment and the North Carolina Constitution protect against unreasonable seizures, and a traffic stop is a seizure.

If the stop was unlawful, the remedy is a motion to suppress. Everything that flowed from the stop — observations of odor and speech, field sobriety tests, the breath test — can be excluded. In a DWI case that often means the State has nothing left to prove. Our guide to the findings a judge must make on suppression explains the procedure.

The question in a weaving case is not whether the driver was impaired. It is whether the officer had enough, before the blue lights came on, to make the stop.Adkins & Purkey

“Weaving plus”: how the Court of Appeals framed the rule

For two decades the North Carolina Court of Appeals followed what scholars call the “weaving plus” doctrine: weaving within a lane could support a DWI stop when combined with at least one other suspicious fact. The Court of Appeals itself used that label in State v. Derbyshire, citing a UNC School of Government blog post by Jeff Welty.

The “plus” factors the cases recognized include:

  • Speed well below the limit. State v. Aubin (1990): weaving plus slowing to about 45 mph on the interstate; State v. Jones (1989): weaving plus driving 20 mph under the limit.
  • Unusual hour plus bar area. State v. Watson (1996): about 2:30 a.m. near a nightclub, weaving on the center line for 15 seconds; State v. Jacobs (2004): 1:43 a.m. near bars, touching lane markers on both sides for three-quarters of a mile.
  • Leaving the lane. State v. Simmons (2010): weaving within and across lanes and running off the road.

On the other side, the court threw out stops built on weaving alone. In State v. Fields (2009), a detective followed a car for about a mile and a half at 4:00 p.m. and saw it swerve to the right line three times. The court held that weaving within a lane, “standing alone,” was not enough, noting the driver was not speeding or going unusually slow, it was not an unusual hour, and he was not near places that sell alcohol. In State v. Peele (2009), one weave over a tenth of a mile, plus an unverified anonymous tip, was also not enough. (For the tip side of Peele, see our guide to reasonable suspicion for DWI stops.)

State v. Otto: when constant weaving is enough

In 2012 the Supreme Court of North Carolina held that weaving can supply reasonable suspicion without a lane violation when it is “constant and continual.” In State v. Otto, a trooper in Pitt County followed a Ford Explorer on NC 43 around 11:00 p.m. and saw it “constantly weaving from the center line to the fog line” for about three-quarters of a mile, at the speed limit and without ever leaving its lane.

The Court of Appeals had suppressed the stop under the weaving-plus line. The Supreme Court reversed. It distinguished Fields (three weaves in a mile and a half) and Peele (one weave) because Otto’s weaving was continuous, and it added that the stop happened around 11:00 p.m. on a Friday. The Court also rejected a trial-court finding that the trooper “knew” a nearby equestrian center served alcohol, because the evidence did not support it — a reminder that every “plus” factor must be proven, not assumed.

A North Carolina State Highway Patrol cruiser without a roof light bar, known as a slick top
Otto and Kochuk both involved state troopers watching a car’s lane position before stopping it. NCSHP “slick top” cruiser. Photo: Joshuabullochx, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Shortly before Otto, the Court of Appeals had also upheld a weaving-only stop in a second case named State v. Fields (2012), where the driver’s weaving was so erratic that other drivers took evasive action and the officer described the car as moving “like a ball bouncing in a small room.” After Otto and the 2012 Fields case, weaving alone can be enough when it is either constant and continuous or erratic and dangerous.

Kochuk and Derbyshire: the line after Otto

Two 2013 decisions show how close the calls are. In State v. Kochuk, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals per curiam for the reasons in the dissent. A trooper on Interstate 40 saw the driver briefly cross the right dotted line once while in the middle lane, change lanes legally, and then ride the fog line twice; the stop came at 1:10 a.m. The dissent, now the law of that case, said weaving plus the early-morning hour was reasonable suspicion under Otto.

Months later, in State v. Derbyshire, the Court of Appeals went the other way. A Raleigh officer saw a car with very bright headlights on Glenwood Avenue at about 10:05 p.m. on a Wednesday, turned around, saw it weave once with its right tires crossing into the next lane, and stopped it near Peace Street. The court held that one weave was neither “constant and continuous” nor “erratic and dangerous,” and that a Wednesday at 10:05 p.m. and bright halogen headlights were too ordinary to be “plus” factors. It called driving at that hour “utterly ordinary.” The stop was unlawful.

A restaurant at the corner of Peace Street and Glenwood Avenue in Raleigh, North Carolina
The Derbyshire stop happened on Glenwood Avenue near Peace Street in Raleigh. Photo: -ted, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.
State v. Otto
366 N.C. 134, 726 S.E.2d 824 (2012) · N.C. Supreme Court

Constant and continual weaving within the lane for about three-quarters of a mile, around 11:00 p.m. on a Friday, gave the trooper reasonable suspicion. Weaving need not cross a line to count.

Read the opinion ↗
State v. Fields
195 N.C. App. 740, 673 S.E.2d 765 (2009) · N.C. Court of Appeals

Three swerves to the right line over 1.5 miles at 4:00 p.m., with no other suspicious facts, was weaving “standing alone” and did not justify the stop. Evidence suppressed.

Read the opinion ↗
State v. Kochuk
366 N.C. 549 (2013) (per curiam) · N.C. Supreme Court

Adopting the Court of Appeals dissent (223 N.C. App. 301): crossing a dotted line once, riding the fog line twice, and the 1:10 a.m. hour together supported reasonable suspicion under Otto.

Read the opinion ↗
State v. Derbyshire
228 N.C. App. 670 (2013) · N.C. Court of Appeals

One weave at 10:05 p.m. on a Wednesday, plus bright headlights, was not reasonable suspicion. Ordinary times and ordinary equipment are not “plus” factors.

Read the opinion ↗
State v. Peele
196 N.C. App. 668, 675 S.E.2d 682 (2009) · N.C. Court of Appeals

A single weave within the lane over a tenth of a mile at about 7:50 p.m., combined with an uncorroborated anonymous “possible DWI” tip, did not justify the stop.

Read the opinion ↗
State v. Aubin
100 N.C. App. 628, 397 S.E.2d 653 (1990) · N.C. Court of Appeals

Weaving within the lane while slowing to about 45 mph on the interstate gave a trooper reasonable suspicion of impaired driving, following State v. Jones (1989).

Read the opinion ↗

North Carolina weaving cases at a glance

Lined up in order, the cases show a clear pattern: the more continuous the weaving and the later the hour, the more likely the stop survives.

CaseWhat the officer sawTimeStop valid?
Aubin (1990)Weaving in lane, slowing to ~45 mph on interstateNot a factorYes
Watson (1996)On center line, weaving 15 seconds, near nightclub~2:30 a.m.Yes
Jacobs (2004)Touching lane markers both sides, ¾ mile, near bars1:43 a.m.Yes
Fields (2009)Three drifts to right line over 1.5 miles4:00 p.m.No
Peele (2009)One weave over 0.1 mile plus anonymous tip~7:50 p.m.No
Otto (2012)Constant weaving center line to fog line, ¾ mile~11 p.m. FridayYes
Kochuk (2013)Crossed dotted line once, on fog line twice1:10 a.m.Yes
Derbyshire (2013)One weave into next lane, bright headlights10:05 p.m. WednesdayNo
Facts as described in the opinions above and in Otto and Derbyshire.

Why officers watch for weaving: NHTSA’s visual cues

Officers are trained to treat lane-position problems as one of the strongest roadside signs of impairment. NHTSA’s training booklet, The Visual Detection of DWI Motorists, groups driving cues into four categories and assigns each a probability range that the driver is impaired. It lists weaving, weaving across lane lines, straddling a lane line, swerving, turning with a wide radius, drifting, and almost striking a vehicle or object as lane-position cues.

NHTSA visual DWI cue categories: stated probability ranges

Problems maintaining lane position50–75%
Speed and braking problems45–70%
Vigilance problems55–65%
Judgment problems35–90%
Weaving plus any other cue65%+

Bar length shows the top of each range. Source: NHTSA, The Visual Detection of DWI Motorists (DOT HS 808 677, March 2010).

These figures are training estimates drawn from law-enforcement research, not facts about any particular driver, and they do not decide the legal question. North Carolina courts apply their own case law; a booklet saying weaving is associated with impairment more than half the time did not stop the Court of Appeals from suppressing the stops in Fields, Peele and Derbyshire. They do explain why an officer’s report will often use NHTSA’s exact vocabulary — “drifting,” “straddling,” “weaving across lane lines” — and why the defense should test that vocabulary against the video.

How to analyze a weaving DWI stop in North Carolina

Start with what the officer saw before activating the lights, and only that. Anything learned after the stop — odor, admissions, test results — cannot justify the stop itself. Then measure the observations against the case factors.

  1. Count the weaves

    One or two drifts looks like Fields, Peele or Derbyshire. Continuous, side-to-side movement looks like Otto.

  2. Measure the distance and time

    How far did the officer follow, and for how long? A tenth of a mile is very different from three-quarters of a mile.

  3. Check for line contact

    Did the tires touch or cross a line, or stay inside? Crossing can be a separate lane violation under G.S. 20-146, and touching lines on both sides was a factor in Jacobs and Kochuk.

  4. Note the hour and day

    1:00 a.m. counted in Kochuk; 4:00 p.m. did not in Fields; 10:05 p.m. on a Wednesday was “utterly ordinary” in Derbyshire.

  5. Test every “plus” factor

    Bars nearby? Prove it. Otto rejected an unsupported finding that a venue served alcohol.

  6. Look for innocent explanations

    Wind, a curve, a lane shift, construction, potholes, a truck passing, a driver adjusting a mirror or GPS.

A two-lane road with a double yellow center line leading onto an old bridge
On two-lane roads, the center line and the fog line mark the lane; in Otto the car moved between them without crossing either. Photo: G. Edward Johnson, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0.

Video review: where weaving cases are won and lost

Dash camera video is usually the single most important piece of evidence in a weaving case. The officer’s narrative is written after the arrest; the video shows the driving as it happened. Get it early, before retention periods run, using the steps in our guide to getting dashcam and bodycam footage.

  • Does the recording begin before the first weave the officer describes?
  • Count each movement toward a line; compare with the report
  • Do the tires touch, cross, or stay inside the lines?
  • Note speed changes, braking, and following distance
  • Check road features: curves, lane shifts, merges, work zones, potholes
  • Note weather, wind and passing trucks
  • Compare the timestamp to the stated time of the stop
  • Check whether the officer’s own car drifts, which shows camera angle effects

Camera angle can make a car look closer to a line than it is, and a curve can look like a drift on a dashboard screen. Watching the clip frame by frame against a map of the road often changes the picture. If there is no video at all, the officer’s memory and report become the whole case, and cross-examination on distance, speed and line contact becomes critical.

When weaving becomes a lane violation

If a car actually leaves its lane, the analysis may change, because the officer may have seen a violation of G.S. 20-146 rather than mere weaving. Courts look at whether leaving the lane was “practicable” to avoid and whether it was done safely, so a single momentary touch is not automatically a violation. Officers sometimes cite other equipment or traffic issues as the reason for a stop; if the officer was mistaken about the law, the stop may still be upheld if the mistake was reasonable, as the U.S. Supreme Court held in a North Carolina case explained in our Heien v. North Carolina guide.

Other driving behavior can supply the “plus” factor too. A long delay at a green light was addressed in State v. Barnard, and weather conditions were part of the analysis in State v. Johnson. More cases are collected in our NC DWI case-law library.

A yellow roadside warning sign reading Rumble Strips Ahead
Road features such as rumble strips, curves and lane shifts can explain drifting that a report calls weaving. Photo: Judahdavis, Wikimedia Commons, Public domain.

Weaving stops around Charlotte, Lake Norman and Stanly County

Weaving is one of the most common reasons given for late-night DWI stops on local interstates and two-lane highways. The same case law applies everywhere in the state; what changes is the road, the agency and the video system.

Stop or no stop? Test yourself

Each scenario below is based on the facts of a real North Carolina appellate decision discussed above.

At 4:00 p.m., an officer follows a car for 1.5 miles and sees it drift to the right line three times. Nothing else is unusual. Valid stop?

  1. Yes, three weaves is enough
  2. No, that is weaving standing alone

State v. Fields (2009) suppressed this stop.

Around 11 p.m. on a Friday, a trooper watches a car weave constantly from center line to fog line for three-quarters of a mile. Valid stop?

  1. Yes
  2. No, it never left its lane

State v. Otto (2012): constant and continual weaving plus the hour was reasonable suspicion.

At 10:05 p.m. on a Wednesday, a car with bright headlights weaves once into the next lane. Valid stop?

  1. Yes, the headlights are a plus factor
  2. No

State v. Derbyshire (2013): one weave, an ordinary hour and bright headlights were not enough.

At 1:10 a.m., a car crosses a dotted line once and later rides the fog line twice. Valid stop?

  1. Yes
  2. No

State v. Kochuk (2013): the Supreme Court adopted the dissent finding reasonable suspicion.

What to do if you were stopped for weaving

Write down your route, the time, the road conditions and anything that might explain your lane position, then get the video requested quickly. Keep in mind that the license side runs on its own clock: a 30-day civil revocation may start immediately, and a suppression win in court does not automatically undo it. Bring your paperwork to a consultation using our consultation checklist.

Charged with DWI in North Carolina?A practical guide to the stop, the science, the DMV & the defenseChris Adkins · Chris Purkey

From our book

Charged with DWI in North Carolina?

Our book explains how DWI stops begin, what officers are trained to watch for on the road, and how the defense tests whether a stop was lawful before anything else in the case is considered.

Get the ebook at Barnes & Noble ↗

Frequently asked questions

Can police stop you for weaving within your lane in North Carolina?

Sometimes. Weaving within a lane is not itself a traffic violation, and weaving standing alone was not enough in State v. Fields (2009). But constant and continual weaving (State v. Otto, 2012), erratic and dangerous weaving, or weaving plus factors like a very late hour or nearby bars can give an officer reasonable suspicion.

Is touching the fog line a traffic violation in NC?

Touching a line is not automatically a violation. G.S. 20-146 requires driving as nearly as practicable entirely within a single lane. Courts treat line contact as one factor; in State v. Kochuk, riding the fog line twice plus crossing a dotted line at 1:10 a.m. supported a stop.

Does the time of night matter for a weaving stop?

Yes. Late hours counted in Otto (11 p.m. Friday) and Kochuk (1:10 a.m.), while 4:00 p.m. in Fields and 10:05 p.m. on a Wednesday in Derbyshire were treated as ordinary.

What happens if the weaving stop was illegal?

The defense can file a motion to suppress. If the judge finds no reasonable suspicion, evidence gathered after the stop, including observations, field tests and breath results, can be excluded, which often ends the criminal case.

How do I prove I was not weaving?

Dash and body camera video is the best evidence. Request it quickly, compare it to the officer’s report, and look at road features, weather and camera angle that may explain lane position.

Traffic in marked lanes on Interstate 77 in Charlotte, North Carolina, where weaving within a lane can lead to a DWI stop
Interstate 77 in Charlotte. Photo: Adam Moss, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

Related guides

Adkins & Purkey, PLLC

Talk to a North Carolina DWI lawyer

If you were stopped for weaving, we will compare the officer’s account to the video and the case law before anything else. Offices in Huntersville (Lake Norman) and Locust (Stanly County), serving Charlotte, Mecklenburg, Iredell, Cabarrus, Stanly and courts across North Carolina.

CA
Written by Chris Adkins & Chris Purkey, Adkins & Purkey, PLLC

Chris Adkins is a former Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer who made several hundred DWI arrests before becoming a defense attorney; he and Chris Purkey have defended hundreds of DWI clients across North Carolina and co-wrote Charged with DWI in North Carolina?

Reviewed November 2026 · Huntersville & Locust, NC

General North Carolina legal information as of November 2026, not legal advice for any specific case. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.