Court process · Pretrial motions
A motion to suppress in a DWI case in NC asks the judge to throw out evidence the State obtained illegally, such as a stop without reasonable suspicion or an arrest without probable cause. In district court these motions follow special rules in G.S. 20-38.6: they must be made before trial, the judge first issues a written preliminary ruling, and the State can appeal a ruling in your favor to superior court before the case ends.
Every strong DWI defense asks the same first question: did the officer have the legal right to do what he did? If the stop, the arrest, the breath test or the blood draw was unlawful, the evidence that came from it may be excluded, and without that evidence the State often cannot prove its case. North Carolina handles those challenges in impaired-driving cases with a procedure found nowhere else in the criminal code. This guide explains how it works as of November 2026, including a June 2026 Court of Appeals decision on the written-ruling requirement. Chris Adkins and Chris Purkey explain these motions in more depth in their book, linked below.
What a motion to suppress does in a NC DWI case
A motion to suppress asks the court to exclude specific evidence; a motion to dismiss asks the court to end the case. In DWI cases both are governed, in district court, by G.S. 20-38.6.
Targets evidence. Common examples: everything observed after a stop without reasonable suspicion; the breath or blood result after an arrest without probable cause; a breath result taken without the required observation period or in violation of the witness right; a warrantless blood draw; or statements taken in violation of Miranda.
Targets the case. Examples: a Knoll motion based on unlawful pretrial detention that cost the defendant access to witnesses; a speedy-trial or other constitutional violation; or, at trial, insufficiency of the evidence after the State rests.
District court first. Misdemeanor DWIs are tried by a district court judge without a jury, and G.S. 20-38.6 and 20-38.7 apply there. If you are convicted and appeal for a new trial in superior court, motions there are handled under the general criminal-procedure rules in Chapter 15A, Article 53.
Suppression works because of the exclusionary rule: evidence obtained in violation of the Fourth Amendment, the North Carolina Constitution, or (in some cases) a substantial violation of Chapter 15A can be excluded. For a deeper look at how judges evaluate the stop and arrest, see State v. Parisi on probable cause, State v. Barnard on reasonable suspicion, and Heien v. North Carolina.
The G.S. 20-38.6 procedure, step by step
The statute requires pretrial motions, a sworn hearing, written findings, and a preliminary ruling that cannot become final until the State decides whether to appeal.
The defendant may move to suppress evidence or dismiss charges only prior to trial, except that a motion to dismiss for insufficient evidence may be made at the close of the State’s evidence and of all the evidence, and a motion may be made during trial based on facts not previously known. The judge must set forth findings of fact and conclusions of law in writing and preliminarily indicate whether the motion should be granted or denied. If the judge preliminarily indicates the motion should be granted, the judge may not enter a final judgment until the State has appealed to superior court or has indicated it does not intend to appeal (close paraphrase).
Read the statute on ncleg.gov ↗- File before trial
The motion must be made before trial unless it rests on facts you did not know earlier. A motion made late, when all the material facts were already known, may be summarily denied (20-38.6(d)).
- State gets time to prepare
The State must be given reasonable time to procure witnesses, evidence and research (20-38.6(b)). Expect the hearing to be set rather than heard on the spot.
- Summary grant, if the State concedes
If the State stipulates that the evidence will not be offered in any criminal proceeding against you, the judge must grant suppression without a hearing (20-38.6(c)).
- Sworn hearing
Otherwise the judge holds a hearing with testimony under oath, usually from the arresting officer, and often with video exhibits (20-38.6(e)).
- Written findings and a preliminary ruling
The judge writes findings of fact and conclusions of law and preliminarily indicates a ruling (20-38.6(f)).
- State’s choice
If the ruling favors you, the State may appeal to superior court or say it will not appeal. If the ruling denies your motion, the case moves on to trial or plea.
- Final order
After any appeal, the case returns to district court, which enters a final order consistent with the superior court’s decision.

The State’s appeal to superior court under G.S. 20-38.7
Only the State gets an immediate appeal: it may take a preliminary ruling granting suppression or dismissal to superior court, while a defendant whose motion is denied must wait and appeal after conviction.
Under G.S. 20-38.7(a), the State may appeal to superior court any district court preliminary determination granting a motion to suppress or dismiss. If the facts are disputed, the superior court is not bound by the district court’s findings and decides the matter de novo, often with a new hearing. Subsection (b) says the defendant may not appeal a denial of a pretrial motion to suppress or dismiss, but may appeal upon conviction as provided by law. That usually means an appeal to superior court for a trial de novo before a jury, where suppression issues can be raised again under the general Chapter 15A rules. Our guide to the plea-or-trial decision explains how this affects strategy.
Key cases on DWI motions procedure
A handful of appellate decisions define how the 20-38.6 and 20-38.7 process actually works, including a 2026 decision making the written ruling a jurisdictional prerequisite to the State’s appeal.
A Mecklenburg County case. The superior court had declared G.S. 20-38.6 and 20-38.7 unconstitutional. The Court of Appeals reversed, holding the procedures do not violate substantive due process, equal protection or double jeopardy, and that the State has no statutory right to appeal a superior court’s 20-38.7 ruling to the Court of Appeals (it reviewed the case by certiorari). It sent the case back for a preliminary ruling treating the probable-cause challenge as a motion to suppress.
Read the opinion ↗The district court gave preliminary notice that it would suppress evidence, and the State gave oral and then written notice of appeal. The Court of Appeals declined to read the 10-day appeal deadline of G.S. 15A-1432(b) into G.S. 20-38.7(a) and held that the superior court erred by refusing to hear the State’s appeal.
Read the opinion ↗The superior court had affirmed a district court’s preliminary indication suppressing a stop for a wide turn across a double yellow line. The Court of Appeals reversed, holding the driver’s maneuver violated traffic statutes and justified the stop, and directed the superior court to remand to district court for a final order denying suppression. It illustrates the remand-and-final-order sequence.
Read the opinion ↗The district court announced in open court that it would suppress, but never entered the written preliminary determination G.S. 20-38.6(f) requires. The majority held the superior court lacked jurisdiction over the State’s appeal, vacated its order, rescinded the defendant’s plea, and remanded for a written ruling. Chief Judge Dillon dissented, viewing the writing requirement as procedural.
Read the UNC School of Government analysis ↗The leading case on motions to dismiss for pretrial-release violations: where magistrates’ statutory violations irreparably prejudiced the defendants’ ability to gather evidence from witnesses, dismissal of the DWI charges was proper.
Read the opinion ↗Dade drew a dissent, so watch for further review. The practical lesson for now is simple: if the judge rules in your favor, make sure a written order with findings and conclusions is actually entered. For more decisions, see our post on State v. Bartlett and suppression findings and the NC DWI case-law library.
What evidence can be challenged
Almost every stage of a DWI investigation can produce a suppression issue, from the reason for the stop to the handling of the blood sample.
| Stage | Typical challenge | Read more |
|---|---|---|
| The stop | No reasonable suspicion; checkpoint not run under its plan | DWI checkpoints |
| Field tests | Improper administration or interpretation of SFSTs and HGN | SFST guide |
| The arrest | No probable cause to believe the driver was impaired | Overocker |
| Breath test | Observation period, rights advisement, witness wait, instrument procedure | Intox EC/IR II |
| Blood test | No warrant, invalid consent, chain of custody, analyst issues | Lab reports |
| Statements | Custodial questioning without Miranda warnings | Miranda and DWI |

Video exhibits and building the record
Suppression hearings are won on the record, and in modern DWI cases the most powerful part of the record is usually video.
An officer’s report may say a car “weaved”; the dashcam may show it stayed in its lane. The report may say the driver “swayed”; the body camera may show steady footing on a sloped shoulder. Because the judge decides the facts at a suppression hearing, a clean video timeline matched to the officer’s testimony can carry the day. Request video early, because retention periods vary by agency; our guide to getting dashcam and bodycam footage explains how. The judge’s written findings also matter beyond district court: they frame what the superior court reviews if the State appeals, and Dade shows what can happen when they are never written down.
How often DWI charges end without a conviction
Statewide court data show that a large share of impaired-driving charges end in something other than a DWI conviction, though the data do not isolate how many result from suppression rulings.
These figures are older and statewide, and they cannot tell you anything about a particular case. A DA dismissal can follow a suppression ruling, a lost witness, a lab problem, or a plea to another charge. The point is narrower: the outcome of a DWI case is not decided at the roadside, and the pretrial-motions stage is where many cases turn. For newer figures, see our NC DWI statistics page and 2022 impaired-driving data.
The question is not only whether you were impaired. It is whether the State can prove it with evidence it was allowed to collect.Adkins & Purkey
Preparing for a suppression hearing
Preparation means collecting every record of the encounter, identifying the specific legal defect, and timing the motion correctly.
- Request dashcam, body-camera and jail video right away.
- Get the breath-test ticket, the rights form (DHHS 4081) and the officer’s affidavit and report.
- Collect the magistrate’s order, release order and civil revocation paperwork.
- Write down your own timeline of the night while it is fresh.
- List witnesses who saw you before, during or after the stop.
- Identify the legal theory: stop, arrest, test procedure, blood draw, statements, or pretrial release.
- Calendar the motion so it is made before trial, as G.S. 20-38.6(a) requires.
Our guides on how to review DWI evidence, breath-testing records and preparing for your consultation walk through the documents in detail.
Quick quiz: DWI motions procedure
Test your understanding of the rules in G.S. 20-38.6 and 20-38.7.
When must most DWI motions to suppress be made in district court?
- Any time during trial
- Before trial
- After the verdict
G.S. 20-38.6(a) allows motions only prior to trial, with narrow exceptions for insufficiency motions and newly discovered facts.
The district judge preliminarily indicates she will suppress the breath result. What happens next?
- The case is dismissed immediately
- The defendant appeals
- The State may appeal to superior court before a final order
Under G.S. 20-38.6(f) and 20-38.7(a), no final judgment is entered until the State appeals or says it will not.
Can a defendant immediately appeal the denial of a pretrial DWI motion to suppress?
- No, only after conviction
- Yes, to superior court
- Yes, to the Court of Appeals
G.S. 20-38.7(b) bars an immediate appeal of a denial; the defendant may appeal upon conviction.
According to State v. Dade (2026), what is required before the State can appeal a suppression ruling?
- A jury verdict
- A written preliminary determination with findings and conclusions
- The defendant’s consent
The Court of Appeals held the written determination under G.S. 20-38.6(f) is a prerequisite to superior court jurisdiction.
Motions practice in Mecklenburg, Iredell, Cabarrus and Stanly
The statute is the same in every county, but scheduling and local practice differ, so motions are usually calendared well ahead of a trial setting.




From our book
Charged with DWI in North Carolina?
Our book explains the stop, the arrest and the testing rules that most suppression motions are built on, and how the evidence is reviewed before a hearing.
Get the ebook at Barnes & Noble ↗ Amazon Kindle ↗ Amazon paperback (print) ↗
Frequently asked questions about DWI motions to suppress
When do I file a motion to suppress in a North Carolina DWI case?
In district court, G.S. 20-38.6(a) requires motions to suppress and dismiss to be made before trial, except for insufficiency motions at the close of the evidence and motions based on facts not previously known.
Can the State appeal if the judge suppresses evidence in my DWI case?
Yes. Under G.S. 20-38.7(a), the State may appeal a district court’s preliminary ruling granting suppression or dismissal to superior court, which decides disputed facts de novo. The district court then enters a final order.
What if the judge denies my motion to suppress?
You cannot appeal the denial immediately. You may appeal upon conviction, usually to superior court for a new trial, where suppression issues can be raised again under the general Chapter 15A rules.
Does the judge have to put the ruling in writing?
Yes. G.S. 20-38.6(f) requires written findings of fact and conclusions of law and a preliminary indication. In State v. Dade (2026), the Court of Appeals held that without that written determination, the superior court lacked jurisdiction over the State’s appeal.
What is the difference between a motion to suppress and a motion to dismiss?
A motion to suppress asks the court to exclude specific evidence, such as a breath result after an unlawful arrest. A motion to dismiss asks the court to end the case, for example under State v. Knoll when unlawful pretrial detention cost the defendant access to witnesses.
Related guides
Adkins & Purkey, PLLC
Talk to a North Carolina DWI lawyer
Whether a motion to suppress or dismiss fits your case depends on the evidence, the video and the timeline, and it has to be raised before trial. Offices in Huntersville (Lake Norman) and Locust (Stanly County), serving Charlotte, Mecklenburg, Iredell, Cabarrus, Stanly and courts across North Carolina.
General North Carolina legal information as of November 2026, not legal advice for any specific case. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Attorney advertising.



